A recent search for UX practitioners in my home region of Wellington, New Zealand, surfaced 14,000 freelance UXers. Fourteen thousand!
Expand the search to people working trans-Tasman, as I do, then add the wider Asia-Pacific market — without even getting into Europe — and the number of potential people, agencies, consultancies and specialists becomes almost meaningless.
Then add the fact that UX is no longer neatly contained within the UX profession. Researchers, product managers, business analysts, developers, marketers and AI-enabled designers can all offer some version of "UX".
So how do you choose who is right for your project?
More importantly: how do you choose the option that creates the least risk for your team?
The answer isn't necessarily to find the "best UXer".
It's to find the right shape of expertise for the problem you actually have.
Four ways to bring design and UX expertise into your team
There are four common ways to do it.
1. Hire a consultancy
2. Hire a digital, creative or specialist agency directly
3. Hire someone permanently
4. Hire a contractor or … a fractional UX practitioner
None is inherently better than the others. The trick is understanding what each one is good at and where it might not quite fit. I’ve broken down what each may look like below along with some things you may want to consider for you, your team and your project.
1. Hire a consultancy
A consultancy can be a good choice when the problem is complex, strategic or needs a broader range of expertise.
You might get access to researchers, strategists, designers, service designers, technologists and project leadership without having to build that capability yourself.
Why it can work
Good for large or complex transformation projects
Access to multiple specialist skills
Useful when you need an external perspective
Can bring structure to an ambiguous problem
Capacity can scale as the project develops.
The thing to consider
Sometimes the consultancy becomes a layer between you and the people actually doing the work and they may bring in a partner agency or additional suppliers.
That isn't necessarily a problem. But if your internal team already has Product Owners, BAs, project managers or delivery leads, you need to be clear about who is doing what.
Not all project sizes need a full consultancy structure.
2. Hire a digital, creative or specialist agency directly
An agency gives you a ready-made team.
Typically that might include UX, UI, visual design, development, strategy, project management and account management.
This can be particularly useful when you need to take something from idea through to delivery and don't have the capability internally.
Why it can work
One team can cover multiple disciplines
Strong delivery capability
Useful for websites, digital products and campaigns
Less internal coordination required
Can move quickly when the scope is reasonably well defined.
The thing to consider
You may already have some of these capabilities in-house.
If your organisation has a Product Owner, BA, delivery manager, technical lead and marketing team, bringing in an agency with its own versions of those roles can create some duplication.
You can end up paying for project and account management around a problem your own team is already very capable of managing.
This team also won’t know the business like your in-house stakeholders and team do, or what other projects you have on elsewhere, so it can lead to complicated user journies you didn’t anticipate or complicated tech stacks as they use their own thinking and systems that may differ from teams elsewhere in your existing business.
Again, that's not bad. It's just a question of what you actually need to buy.
3. Hire someone permanently
Building UX capability into your organisation can make enormous sense when design is going to be an ongoing part of how you work.
An embedded designer learns your customers, systems, constraints, stakeholders and organisational quirks.
Over time, that knowledge becomes incredibly valuable.
Why it can work
Deep organisational knowledge
Strong relationships with stakeholders
Continuity across projects
Design becomes part of everyday decision-making
No need to repeatedly onboard external people.
The thing to consider
Where UX sits in the organisation matters.
I've worked in technology teams and marketing teams, and both can create different challenges around priorities, influence and allegiance.
A designer embedded in one part of an organisation can sometimes end up optimising for that team's needs rather than the wider customer or business problem.
And of course, a permanent hire is a significant commitment. You need enough ongoing work to justify the role not just one large project.
4. Hire a contractor or… a fractional UX practitioner
This is the option that is sometimes overlooked.
You don't necessarily need an agency and you don't necessarily need another permanent employee.
And you for sure don’t need a UXer for three weeks to produce some wireframes and disappear.
A contractor can become a temporary extension of your team, working alongside your existing people and filling a specific capability gap.
And fractional UXer can be particularly useful when your needs are cyclical.
Perhaps:
you need design support every quarter
your product changes significantly each term, season or year
you need someone to come in, understand what's happening, test the experience, identify opportunities and help the team make improvements and then return a few months later with fresh eyes.
Why it can work
Flexible access to senior expertise
No permanent headcount commitment
Works alongside your existing Product, BA, technology or marketing teams
Useful for periods of change or increased workload
Can provide continuity without requiring a full-time role
Fresh eyes each time they return
You buy the expertise you need rather than an entire team.
The thing to consider
A contractor still needs to be embedded properly.
Give them no context, no access to customers and no relationship with the team, and you may just get deliverables.
BUT give them enough time, access and trust to understand the problem, and you can get considerably more value.
Fractional doesn't have to mean one-off. Sometimes the best arrangement is someone who works with your team at key points throughout the year.
So what should you choose?
The answer depends less on the size of your project and more on the capability you already have.
If you have no internal delivery capability and need everything from strategy to development, an agency may make sense.
If you're tackling a large organisational transformation, a consultancy might be the right structure.
If design is a permanent and growing part of your product operation, build the capability internally.
But if you already have strong Product, BA, technology and delivery people and what you're missing is senior UX thinking and design capability, bringing in one experienced practitioner can sometimes be the simplest answer.
You don't need another layer, you need the missing piece.
And this is where the fit matters
There are now plenty of people who can:
produce a wireframe
run user interviews
use AI to generate a prototype
And there are plenty of people who have picked up UX skills as part of another discipline.
All those skills can absolutely be useful but there is a difference between being able to do UX activities and having the experience to know what to do, when to do it, and importantly when not to do it.